Appendix 1: Regulatory Impact Summary Table*
Fiscal Costs	FY 2018	FY 2019	FY 2020	
State Government	$0	$0	$0	
Local Government	$0	$0	$0	
Small Businesses	$0	$0	$0	
Non-Small Businesses	$0	$0	$0	
Other Person	$0	$0	$0	
Total Fiscal Costs:	$0	$0	$0	
				
Fiscal Benefits				
State Government	$0	$0	$0	
Local Government	$0	$0	$0	
Small Businesses	$0	$0	$0	
Non-Small Businesses	$0	$0	$0	
Other Persons	$0	$0	$0	
Total Fiscal Benefits:	$0	$0	$0	
				
Net Fiscal Benefits:	$0	$0	$0	
*This table only includes fiscal impacts that could be measured. If there are inestimable fiscal impacts, they will not be included in this table. Inestimable impacts for State Government, Local Government, Small Businesses and Other Persons are described above. Inestimable impacts for Non-Small Businesses are described below.

Appendix 2: Regulatory Impact to Non-Small Businesses

This rule repeal does not carry any fiscal impact. The repeal is accompanied by a separate rule filing enacting a new rule, R746-8. Any fiscal impact that may indirectly result from this rule repeal is discussed in that rule filing.
PSC Chair Thad LeVar has reviewed and approved this fiscal analysis.

R746.  Public Service Commission, Administration.
[R746-343.  Rule for Deaf, Severely Hearing or Speech Impaired Person.
R746-343-1.  Purpose and Authority.
	This rule is to establish a program as required in Section 54-8b-10 which will provide telecommunication devices to certified deaf, or severely hearing or speech impaired persons, who qualify under certain conditions, and to provide a dual relay system using third party intervention to connect deaf or severely hearing or speech impaired persons with normal hearing persons by way of telecommunication devices.

R746-343-2.  Definitions.
	A.  Definitions
	1.  "Applicant" is a person applying for a Telecommunication Device for the Deaf, signal device, or other communication device.
	2.  "Audiologist" is a person who has a Master's or Doctoral degree in Audiology, is licensed in Audiology in Utah, and holds the Certificate of Clinic Competence in Audiology from the American Speech/Language/Hearing Association, or its equivalent.
	3.  "Deaf" is a hearing loss that requires the use of a TDD to communicate effectively on the telephone.
	4.  "Provider" is a service provider who agrees to be, if determined by the Public Service Commission, the administrator of the program or a portion of the program.
	5.  "Distribution center" is a facility authorized by the provider to distribute TDDs and signal devices, personal communicators, or other devices required by a recipient to communicate effectively on the telephone.
	6.  "Dual relay system" is the provision of voice and teletype communication between users of TDDs and other parties.
	7.  "Otolaryngologist" is a licensed physician specializing in ear, nose and throat medicine.
	8.  "Recipient" is a person who receives a TDD, signal device, personal communicator, or other device to communicate effectively on the telephone.
	9.  "Speech language pathologist" is a person who has a Master's or Doctoral degree in Speech Language Pathology in Utah, and holds the Certificate of Clinical Competence in Speech/Language Pathology from the American Speech Language Hearing Association, or its equivalent.
	10.  "Severely hearing impaired" is a hearing loss that requires use of TDD to communicate effectively on the telephone.
	11.  "Severely Speech Impaired" is a speech handicap, or disorder, that renders speech on an ordinary telephone unintelligible.
	12.  "Signal device" is a mechanical device that alerts a deaf, deaf-blind, or severely hearing impaired person of an incoming telephone call.
	13.  "Telecommunications Device for the Deaf, or TDD, is an electrical device for use with a telephone that utilizes a key board.  It may also have an acoustic coupler, display screen or braille display to transmit and receive messages.
	14.  "Telephone relay center" is a facility administered by the provider to provide dual relay service.
	15.  "Commission" is the Utah Public Service Commission.

R746-343-3.  Eligibility Requirements.
	A.  An applicant is eligible if he is deaf, severely hearing impaired, or severely speech impaired and is eligible for assistance under a low income public assistance program.  The impairment must be established by the certification on an application form by a person who is permitted to practice medicine in Utah, an audiologist, otolaryngologist, speech/language pathologist, or qualified personnel within a state agency.  The applicant must provide evidence that they are currently eligible, though it is not necessary that they be participating in a low income public assistance program.
	C.  The provider may require additional documentation to determine applicant's eligibility.
	D.  During the training session required in Section R746-343-8, Training, the applicant must demonstrate an ability to send and receive messages with a TDD or other appropriate devices.

R746-343-4.  Approval of an Application.
	A.  Approved Application--
	1.  When an original application has been approved, the provider shall inform the applicant in writing of:
	a.  when the original application has been approved;
	b.  the location of the distribution center or designated place where the applicant may receive a TDD;
	c.  the date and time of the training session as required in Section R746-343-8.
	2.  When the request for a replacement TDD, signal device, or other device has been approved, the provider or the distribution center shall inform the recipient of the procedure for obtaining a replacement device.
	B.  Denied Applications--If an original application or replacement request is denied, the provider shall inform the applicant in writing of the reasons for the denial and of applicable procedures for appeal.  Denial notices shall be sent by mail.  The notice shall be accompanied by instructions on the review process.

R746-343-5.  Review by the Provider.
	A.  An applicant or recipient whose request for an original or replacement device has been denied may request that the provider review the decision.
	B.  The request for review shall be in writing and shall specify the basis for review and must be received by the provider within 30 days of the receipt of the notice of denial.
	C.  Within ten days of receiving the request for review, the provider shall inform the applicant or recipient in writing of the disposition of the request.

R746-343-6.  Review by the Commission.
	A.  Within 20 days of the notice of denial from the provider for review, the applicant or recipient may request in writing a hearing by the Commission.  The request shall specify the reasons for challenging the decision.

R746-343-7.  Distribution Process.
	A.  Distribution Centers shall:
	1.  Upon notice from the provider, distribute TDDs, signal devices, or other specified devices, to persons determined eligible under Section R746-343-3, Eligibility Requirements, and who reside in Utah;
	2.  Require each recipient or legal guardian to sign an agreement, Condition of Acceptance, form supplied by the provider;
	3.  Forward completed application forms and agreement forms to the provider;
	4.  Inform the provider of those applicants who fail to report for training and receipt of devices.
	B.  The provider shall implement a program to facilitate distribution of devices and provide training as required.
	C.  Neither the distribution center nor the provider shall be responsible for providing replacement paper for devices, the payment of the recipient's monthly telephone bill, purchase or lease cost of recipient's telephone, or the cost of replacement light bulbs for signal devices.

R746-343-8.  Training.
	A.  The provider shall be responsible for seeing that training is provided to each recipient and legal guardian, or significant other, in accordance with guidelines established by the provider.

R746-343-9.  Replacement Devices.
	A.  The distribution center shall provide devices to persons determined by the provider to be eligible under Sections R746-343-3, Eligibility Requirements, and R746-343-8, Training, accept devices that need repair, and deliver devices returned by recipients to a repair center designated by the provider.

R746-343-10.  Ownership and Liability.
	A.  TDDs, signal devices, and other devices provided by this program are the property of the state.
	B.  A recipient or guardian shall return a TDD, signal device, or other device, to the provider or distribution center when the recipient no longer intends to reside in Utah, is no longer qualified for the program, does not need the device, or has been notified by the provider to return the device.
	C.  Other than normal usage, recipients are liable for damage to or loss of a device issued under conditions of acceptance.

R746-343-11.  Out of State Use.
	No person shall remove a TDD, signal device, or other device from the state for a period longer than 90 days without written permission of the provider.

R746-343-12.  Dual Relay Service--Telephone Relay Center.
	A.  A telephone relay center shall provide dual relay service seven days a week, 24 hours a day, including holidays.
	B.  A telephone relay center shall hire operators with specialized communication skills who shall be salaried employees.
	C.  A telephone relay center shall require the operators to relay each message accurately, except as otherwise specifically provided in Section R746-343-14, Criminal Activity.

R746-343-13.  Confidentiality and Privacy Requirements.
	A.  Except as otherwise specifically provided in Section R746-343-14, Criminal Activity, a telephone relay center shall protect the privacy of persons to whom relay services are provided and shall require each operator to maintain the confidentiality of each telephone message.
	B.  The confidentiality and privacy of persons to whom relay services are provided will be protected by means of the following:
	1.  The relay center shall not maintain any form of permanent copies of messages relayed by their operators or allow the content of telephone messages relayed by their operators to be communicated to non-staff members.
	2.  Persons using the relay system shall not be required to provide identifying information until the party they are calling is on line, and shall only be required to identify themselves to the extent necessary to fulfill the purpose of their call.
	3.  Relay operators shall not leave messages with third parties unless instructed to do so by the person making the call.
	4.  Persons using the relay system may file complaints about the relay service to the telephone relay center or the provider, who shall review each complaint.

R746-343-14.  Criminal Activity.
	A.  Relay operators shall not knowingly transmit telephone messages that are made in furtherance of a criminal activity as defined by Utah or federal law.
	B.  The confidentiality and privacy requirements of Section R746-343-13, Confidentiality and Privacy Requirements, do not apply to telephone conversations made in furtherance of a criminal activity as defined by Utah or federal law.

R746-343-16.  New Technology Equipment Distribution Program (NTEDP).
	(1)  Authority and Purpose.
	(a)  This rule section is promulgated pursuant to Utah Code Subsection 54-8b-10(3)(b).
	(b)  The purposes of the NTEDP are:
	(i)  to explore the feasibility of using tablet devices and/or unlocked cellular telephones to address the telecommunication needs of the deaf, severely hearing-impaired, and severely speech-impaired communities;
	(ii)  to determine how best to manage a program in which tablet devices and/or unlocked cellular telephones are provided; and
	(iii)  to determine the level of support services that would be required if tablet devices and/or unlocked cellular telephone devices are provided.
	(2)  Duration.  The NTEDP shall terminate no later than December 31, 2018.
	(3)  Participation.
	(a)  An individual who wishes to participate in the NTEDP shall:
	(i)  submit a completed application form to the Relay Utah office;
	(ii)  provide medical documentation of:
	(A)  deafness;
	(B)  severe hearing impairment; or
	(C)  severe speech impairment;
	(iii)  demonstrate that the individual is receiving assistance from a low-income public assistance program administered by a state agency;
	(iv)(A)  if applying for a tablet, certify that the individual has consistent access to a WiFi network; or
	(B)  if applying for an unlocked cellular telephone, certify that the individual has a service plan in place with a wireless telecommunications provider; and
	(v)  certify that the individual is able and willing to comply with Subsection (4).
	(b)  Priority may be given to applicants who have previously participated in the Commission's Relay Utah program.
	(c)  An applicant who is not selected to participate may request to be placed on a waiting list.
	(d)  Participation shall be limited as follows:
	(i)  From the inception of the program through June 30, 2017, no more than 25 participants, as follows:
	(A)  no more than 8 deaf individuals who are at least 13 years old;
	(B)  no more than 8 severely hearing-impaired individuals who are at least 13 years old;
	(C)  no more than 8 severely speech-impaired individuals who are at least 13 years old; and
	(D)  at least one deaf, severely hearing-impaired, or severely speech-impaired individual who is under 13 years of age.
	(ii)  From July 1, 2017 through the conclusion of the program, up to 10 additional participants in each six-month period.
	(4)  Participant obligations.
	(a)  An individual who is chosen to participate in the NTEDP shall:
	(i)  participate in an entrance interview with the Relay Utah office;
	(ii)  complete online surveys as instructed by the Relay Utah office;
	(iii)  promptly comply with all instructions from the Relay Utah office to download apps;
	(iv)  promptly respond to requests from the Relay Utah office for information and feedback;
	(v)  maintain the device in the storage case provided;
	(vi)  retain all original device packaging, instructions, and information;
	(vii)  contact the manufacturer's customer service department for assistance with technical support;
	(viii)  promptly report to the Relay Utah office:
	(A)  software and hardware failures; and
	(B)  damage to the device;
	(ix)  take financial responsibility for loss of, or damage to, the device if caused by the individual's misuse or negligence; and
	(x)  immediately return the device to the Relay Utah office if the individual:
	(A)  moves from the State of Utah;
	(B)  is disqualified by the Relay Utah office from further participation in the NTEDP; or
	(C)  chooses to terminate the individual's participation in the NTEDP.
	(b)  An individual who is chosen to participate in the NTEDP may not:
	(i)  reformat or attempt to reformat the device;
	(ii)  allow any other person to use the device, except as necessary to assist the participant with telecommunications; or
	(iii)  install software, apps, or other programs not authorized by the Relay Utah office.
	(c)  A participant who fails to comply with this Subsection (4) may be disqualified from further participation in the NTEDP.
	(5)  All devices distributed as part of the NTEDP shall remain the property of the State of Utah Public Service Commission.

KEY:  assistive devices and technology, speech/hearing assistance, telecommunications
Date of Enactment or Last Substantive Amendment:  July 10, 2017
Notice of Continuation:  December 10, 2012
Authorizing, and Implemented or Interpreted Law:  54-8b]